Plonit v. Sharia Court of Appeals
High Court · Decided 2025-02-23 · Petition Dismissed Outright; Warning re: Costs/Discipline. · AI tool: Unidentified.
3 AI-hallucination sanctions decided between 2025-02-17 and 2025-02-23 (ISO week 2025-W08). Every ruling below is sourced from the public docket — case name, decided date, outcome, AI tool implicated (when named), and any monetary penalty language pulled verbatim from the ruling.
3 rulings landed on the docket between 2025-02-17 and 2025-02-23. The most common recorded outcome this week was Complaint Dismissed With Prejudice; No Formal Ai-related Sanction Imposed, But Dismissal Explicitly Acknowledged Fictitious Citations As Contributing Factor (1 of 3). Of the 3 rulings, 1 carried an explicit monetary penalty in the ruling text.
Implied was the most-implicated AI tool this week (courts rarely require the attorney to name the tool by product name on the record; “Implied” means the ruling described an AI-generated brief without a product name).
The pattern each week is remarkably stable: existence failures (Layer 1) dominate. Attorneys file briefs containing citations that do not exist in any primary source — usually because a general-purpose LLM fabricated the citation and no deterministic pre-filing check caught it. Every ruling below is a preventable filing. See /verify for the pre-filing tool.
High Court · Decided 2025-02-23 · Petition Dismissed Outright; Warning re: Costs/Discipline. · AI tool: Unidentified.
D. Nevada · Decided 2025-02-18 · Complaint dismissed with prejudice; no formal AI-related sanction imposed, but dismissal explicitly acknowledged fictitious citations as contributing factor · AI tool: Implied.
Ontario SCJ · Decided 2025-02-18 · Costs awarded against Bankrupt · Penalty: 7267 · AI tool: Implied.
Get the Sanctions Alert — a new issue every time a ruling lands.
Free double-opt-in newsletter. Case, sanction, fake cites, lesson. No promotional content.
Informational only. Not legal advice. Data derived from public court records; corrections at /contact.